|
This blind tasting was organized and presented by Frank and Jackie Carson. Twenty one members attended and scored the wines. Other similar tastings are to be held at AWS Chapters with the composite results published in an AWS Newsletter.
Zinfandel is celebrated as one of California’s oldest wine varietals. Records indicate that Zinfandel arrived in California before the Civil War. The grape is indigenous to Croatia (called Crljenak Kaštelanski) and it is also related to Southern Italy’s Primitivo grape. Zinfandel was first grown in the U.S. during the 1820’s by George Gibbs, a horticulturist on Long Island. These initial vines likely came from the Imperial Nursery in Vienna, Austria.
Members evaluated 6 wines without comments until after the scores for each wine were recorded. The American Wine Society’s 20 point scoring method was used (Appearance - 3 points maximum, Aroma/Bouquet - 6, Taste/Texture - 6, Aftertaste - 3, and Overall Impression - 2.). Four California Zinfandel wine regions/styles were represented (Paso Robles, Sonoma County, Lodi, and a California blend).
The average scores and prices for each wine:
Wine Score Price/Bottle
2006 Peachy Canyon “Incredible Red”, Paso Robles 12.2 $9.89
2007 Seghesio Sonoma County Zinfandel 14.8 $19.99
2005 Ravenswood Sonoma County Old Vine Zinfandel 12.6 $12.99
2006 Gnarly Head Old Vine Zinfandel, Lodi 13.4 $8.99
2006 7 Deadly Zins - Michael & David Phillips, Lodi 13.8 $13.49
2006 Rancho Zabaco “Dancing Bull Zinfandel”, California 12.9 $6.29
The top to bottom rated average scores were separated by only 2.6 points. According to the AWS 20 point maximum scoring method, wines rated “good” range from 12 to 14 and wines rated “excellent” range from 15 to 17.
Examples of comments on these wines included: fruit descriptors (berry, dark berry fruit, chewable red dark fruit, several berry fruits, bright red & black berry, intense mouth filling fruit), jammy, hot (higher alcohol levels), long finish, peppery, spicy, and Chocolate. These are just a few sensations that one might experience from America’s grape, Zinfandel.
The wines were served with a selection of very good cheeses, Parmigiano - Reggiano, Irish Cheddar, and Cambozola, and there was coffee and desserts to conclude.
|